Skip to Content

What Allowing Pets Will Do to Your Rental Property’s ROI

Landlords often find themselves at a crossroads when deciding whether to allow pets in their rental properties. The debate is fueled by concerns about potential damage versus the appeal of attracting a broader tenant base. However, what if allowing pets could improve your rental property’s return on investment (ROI)?

Our experts at RPM Sunstate will explore the impact of allowing pets on rental property ROI and why it might benefit intentional investors.

The Benefits of Allowing Pets in Rental Properties

Allowing pets in rental properties has several advantages that can positively impact your ROI. From expanding your tenant pool to increasing your rental income, welcoming pets can be a strategic move for intentional investors.

Widening Your Tenant Pool

Statistics

Data indicates that a significant portion of renters have pets. According to Forbes, approximately 66% of U.S. households own a pet. Nearly 72% of renters in the rental market have pets or intend to acquire one. This substantial percentage highlights an essential demographic landlords can cater to by adopting pet-friendly policies.

Increased Demand

Allowing pets in your rental property can substantially increase demand. Given the high percentage of renters with pets, properties that welcome pets immediately appeal to a larger pool of potential tenants. 

Pet owners are often willing to pay a premium to ensure their furry friends are accepted, making your property more desirable. This increased demand can lead to quicker occupancy rates, reducing the time your property remains vacant.

Competitive Edge

A pet-friendly policy can provide a significant advantage in a competitive rental market. Many rental properties retain strict no-pet rules, creating a scarcity of pet-friendly options. By allowing pets, your property stands out, attracting responsible pet owners who may find it challenging to secure rental accommodations. 

Moreover, tenants with pets often extend their tenancy periods, as they are less likely to relocate frequently due to the difficulty of finding pet-friendly housing elsewhere. This can result in more stable, long-term rental income for property owners.

A property manager calculating ROI with graphs, a calculator, and a tablet on a desk

Increasing Monthly Rent

Higher Rent Premium

Pet-friendly properties have the potential to command higher rents compared to those with no-pet policies. Tenants with pets are often willing to pay more for the convenience and peace of mind of knowing their pets are welcome. This premium can be a crucial factor in enhancing your property’s profitability. 

Positioning your rental as a pet-friendly option allows you to set a higher base rent, reflecting the added value of accommodating tenants with pets. This increase in rental income can significantly boost your ROI over time.

Pet Fees and Deposits

In addition to higher monthly rents, allowing pets opens up additional revenue streams through pet fees, deposits, and rent. You can implement non-refundable pet fees to cover potential property wear and tear attributed to pets. Security deposits specific to pets, which can be refundable or non-refundable, provide extra financial safeguards for any damage that might occur. 

Furthermore, many landlords charge a monthly pet rent, an additional amount on top of the base rent. These fees compensate for potential risks and contribute to a steady flow of supplementary income, enhancing the overall profitability of your rental property.

Reducing Tenant Turnover and Maximizing ROI

Tenant Retention

Long-term Leases

Pet owners are often more inclined to renew their leases to avoid the hassle of finding new pet-friendly accommodations. The scarcity of properties allowing pets means tenants who find a welcoming home for their furry friends will likely stay longer. This inclination towards long-term leases is advantageous for landlords, as it reduces the frequency and cost of tenant turnover. 

Fewer moves mean less wear and tear on the property, decreasing maintenance costs over time. The loyalty of pet owners, driven by their desire to maintain a stable environment for their pets, translates to more consistent rental income for property owners.

Stability and Reduced Vacancy

Lower tenant turnover rates contribute to more stable and consistent rental income, minimizing vacancy periods. When tenants stay for extended periods, landlords benefit from reduced marketing and administrative expenses associated with finding new renters. 

Additionally, a steady occupancy rate ensures a continuous flow of rental income, enhancing the overall financial stability of the property investment. Stability in tenancy fosters a sense of community within the rental property. It provides landlords with reliable and predictable cash flow, which is critical for long-term financial planning and success.

Cost Savings on Marketing and Turnover

Marketing Costs

One of the significant advantages of allowing pets in your rental property is the cost savings associated with marketing and advertising. With fewer vacancies due to longer tenant retention, landlords spend less on promoting their property.

Extended tenancy periods mean reduced frequency of needing to advertise for new tenants, significantly cutting down on the expenses related to property listings, online advertisements, and even physical signage. This reduction in marketing costs directly contributes to the overall profitability of the investment, as funds that would be spent on tenant acquisition can be allocated instead to other areas of property management or reinvested elsewhere.

Reduced Vacancy Periods

Minimized downtime between tenants is another crucial financial benefit for landlords of pet-friendly properties. Properties that allow pets are more appealing and often experience shorter vacancy periods. Quick turnaround times between tenants mean fewer days or weeks without rental income. 

This consistency in occupancy ensures a steady cash flow, preventing the financial strain that comes with prolonged vacancies. Additionally, reduced vacancy periods lessen the burden of property upkeep and preparation, as the property requires fewer touch-ups and renovations between tenants, leading to further cost savings.

Pet Owners as Ideal Tenants

The common misconception about allowing pets is that it leads to increased property damage, higher costs, and more hassle for landlords. However, studies have shown that pet owners tend to be responsible and reliable tenants because they are motivated to maintain a stable environment for their furry companions.

Increased Responsibility

Responsible pet owners are vested in keeping the rental property well-maintained, as they understand the implications of any damages caused by their pets. They are typically willing to follow the rules and regulations the landlord sets regarding pet care and behavior, contributing to a more peaceful living environment.

Care for Property

Pet owners are often conscientious renters who take good care of their property. A key reason behind this is their understanding of the heightened scrutiny and potential liabilities of having a pet.

Many pet owners are acutely aware of the challenges in securing pet-friendly housing. This motivates them to maintain the property in excellent condition to avoid conflicts with landlords and ensure lease renewal. They tend to keep the home clean and are more likely to adhere to property rules and guidelines, reducing the risk of damages and maintaining overall property quality.

Community and Stability

Pet owners also foster stronger community ties and contribute significantly to neighborhood stability. Usually, having a pet necessitates regular interaction with other pet owners and neighbors during daily walks or community pet events. These interactions can nurture a stronger sense of community and improve relationships with fellow tenants and neighbors. 

Additionally, pet owners usually value a stable and consistent environment for their animals, making them more likely to remain in one place longer. This tendency towards long-term tenancy does not only benefit landlords by reducing turnover and associated costs. It also promotes a more stable and cohesive neighborhood, enhancing the overall living experience for all residents.

Ensuring Compliance and Legal Protection

To ensure a smooth and satisfactory rental experience for both pet owners and landlords, it is essential to have clear policies in place. These can include thorough screening processes for potential tenants with pets and implementing a comprehensive pet addendum.

Legal Framework

Including a pet addendum in your lease agreement is crucial for defining the terms under which pets are allowed on your property. A pet addendum is a legally binding document that outlines the responsibilities and expectations of the tenant and the landlord regarding pet ownership within the rental unit. 

It protects landlords from potential liabilities by clearly stating the rules and consequences related to pets, thus minimizing disputes and misunderstandings. A well-structured pet addendum can also serve as a vital tool in ensuring compliance with local laws and regulations concerning pet housing.

Terms and Conditions

A comprehensive pet addendum should include several key elements to ensure clarity and protection. First, it should specify the types and number of pets allowed, including breed or size restrictions. Additionally, it should outline pet-related fees such as non-refundable pet deposits, monthly pet rent, and any additional charges for damages caused by pets.

The addendum should also detail the tenant’s responsibilities, such as maintaining the cleanliness of the rental unit, properly disposing of pet waste, and ensuring that pets do not disturb other residents. Requirements for vaccinations, licensing, and spaying or neutering should also be stated clearly. It’s essential to include policies on pet supervision and confinement to common areas to prevent any potential issues with other tenants.

Another critical aspect is to specify the landlord’s right to inspect the property to ensure compliance with the pet policies. Lastly, the pet addendum should clearly state the consequences for violating any of its terms, including potential eviction and the forfeiture of pet deposits.

A happy tenant holding her cat in her rental home, ‘should I allow pets in my rental

Maximizing Your Rental Property Investments by Embracing Pet-Friendly Policies

Allowing pets in your rental property can positively impact your ROI by widening your tenant pool, increasing monthly rent, reducing tenant turnover, and attracting responsible renters. With clear policies and legal protections in place, the benefits of a pet-friendly property far outweigh the potential drawbacks.

By considering these factors, landlords can make informed decisions that enhance the profitability and attractiveness of their rental properties. If you’re ready to explore the potential of allowing pets in your rental, contact RPM Sunstate for professional property management services to maximize your ROI.


Download Now

 

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details